Hedge Fund Vs. Private Equity: How Are They Different?

The comparison of a hedge fund vs. private equity fund isn’t overly complex, although there are some nuances to each investment method worth learning. It helps to define the two topics individually to develop a clear understanding of how they work for investors. 

A hedge fund uses pooled funds to drive various investment strategies to earn returns. These funds are aggressively managed and employ multiple stock market investment methods, including purchasing stocks, bonds, currencies, commodity futures, derivatives, and arbitrage. They might also engage in short selling, which is highly risky but can provide significant returns for investors. 

The gist is that hedge funds are looking to achieve short-term profits, and they’ll often use borrowed money to boost their leverage. This allows them to increase their positions when an investment opportunity arises without requiring additional upfront money from investors. Hedge funds are risky, but the reward is usually worth it for investors with high risk tolerance. 

Private equity invests in companies, often by purchasing them directly. They’ll sometimes buy a controlling interest in a publicly traded organization on the stock market but will usually purchase private companies outright. Some private equity firms specialize in the leveraged buyouts of financially distressed businesses. 

Most private equity funds focus on long-term earnings. The goal is to acquire companies, improve them by either changing management, streamlining operations, or expanding, and sell them for a profit. Sometimes they will complete the sale privately, while other times, private equity firms will take the company public on the stock market and sell shares.

Getting a handle on the hedge fund vs. private equity comparison involves looking at the typical investor profile of each type and learning how these firms operate. This guide will take you through the similarities and differences these finance vehicles possess so you can choose your best investment option for the future. 

How Hedge Funds and Private Equity Funds Are Similar

There are many differences between hedge funds and private equity firms, but they also have some similarities. Understanding these similarities makes learning about their differences far more straightforward. Some of the main similarities you’ll find when researching these funds include:

They’re for High-Net-Worth Investors

The investor profile for hedge funds and private equity funds is similar, at least when it comes to net worth. Both investment types typically appeal to those with significant cash flow, and many require a minimum investment of $250,000 or more to get involved. The result is a relatively small segment of society with access to these funds and the earnings that go along with them.

Hedge fund investors looking over graphs

They Practice Risk Management

Risk management is vital to hedge fund and private equity fund managers because neither wants to lose all their investors’ money. The gist is that both funds will combine high-risk investments with safer options to provide a safety net if something goes wrong short term. It’s worth noting, however, that hedge funds often engage in riskier investments than private equity funds because they aim to make money faster.

They Offer Significant Returns

The main reason high-net-worth investors choose these funds is that they offer potential returns far higher than the public equity market or through purchasing businesses as an individual. These funds have significant amounts of money to invest, creating greater purchasing power and using this leverage to their advantage. Anyone serious about making money on investments at a meaningful level should look into these funds and their benefits.

They’re Structured as Limited Partnerships

Hedge fund and private equity fund investments have structures that define them as limited partnerships. This is when two or more entities go into business together, but the limited partners only have liability up to the amount of their investment. This structure means investors can lose all the money they put into the fund but can’t lose anything else if a strategy falters.

They Have Management Fees

Both forms of investment have managing partners who will receive fees and a percentage of profits. These partners also have unlimited liability, so they’re taking on significant risks throughout the process. Managing partners also stand to make a substantial profit when the funds do well, as it isn’t rare for administrators to earn more than $1 million per year.

These similarities are worth exploring as you determine which fund type would help you reach your financial goals. It all comes down to your risk tolerance and how much time you’re willing to wait for a return. Learning as much as possible about how each format works gives you greater insight into how they can maximize your returns on a timeline you can accept.

7 Hedge Fund Vs. Private Equity Fund Differences

Similarities exist when comparing hedge funds and private equity funds, but there are also many differences. The hedge fund vs. private equity debate is significant for high-profile investors, and learning about how they deviate from each other helps you understand why this is the case. Some of the main differences include:

1. Investment Risks

Hedge funds tend to make riskier investments than private equity funds. The main reason is that hedge funds focus on short-term gains, and taking high-risk positions is the only way to reach these goals. Private equity funds, on the other hand, are happy to watch their investments grow slowly over time, allowing them to go for lower-risk options while still attaining significant long-term growth.

2. Lock-Up Period

The lock-up period of an investment refers to the amount of time the money invested will be unavailable to the investor. Hedge funds and private equity funds require significant capital from each investor, but their lock-up periods are usually different. The typical private equity fund might require a lock-up period spanning multiple years because this gives the investment time to grow, while a hedge fund’s lock-up period is often measurable in weeks or months.

3. Investment Time Horizon

Time horizon is similar to the lock-up period, but it focuses on when you can expect to see profits on your investment. Hedge funds operate quickly, as each transaction could take anywhere from a few seconds to a couple of years to complete, providing fast earnings in many cases. Private equity is different because it involves buying a company and working to make it profitable, so the time horizon is typically five to seven years.

4. Legal Structure

The two investment types have different legal structures. Hedge funds are opened-ended and, therefore, don’t have any restrictions on transferability and allow investors to add more funds at any time. Private equity funds are closed-ended, so there are restrictions on transferability within a specific time frame and prohibitions on adding funds after the initial investment period.

5. Fee Structure

We know that investors are on the hook for some fees with both fund types, but this compensation structure differs. Hedge fund managers generally receive payments based on a high-water mark calculated using the Net Asset Value. Private equity funds typically charge investors a 2% management fee in addition to a 20% incentive fee, based on the fund’s value crossing hurdle rates.

6. Capital Investment

How the fund manager invests is also different, depending on the fund type. A hedge fund typically invests all the money at one time, which helps maximize the return in a short interval. A private equity fund investor only has to put up money when called upon, although failing to honor capital calls could lead to severe penalties from the fund manager.

7. Taxes

There could be differences in how taxes are calculated on your earnings from hedge funds and private equity funds. Both investment types require submitting a Schedule K-1 to the IRS, which reports income, losses, and dividends. Hedge fund earnings on investments of less than a year are subject to short-term capital gains, which are taxed at income tax rates, while private equity earnings are generally taxed at the long-term capital gains rate.

Comparing hedge funds and private equity funds is a valid exercise as you determine how to best achieve your financial goals. Either option can be viable for a high-net-worth investor, but many other investment opportunities exist if these options don’t work for your situation.

Investing Your Money With Expert Help

Private equity funds invest in many different industries, so determining the area with the highest growth potential over time is a challenge. Cybersecurity is worth considering because the need for these firms will continue to grow every year, and the growth potential is immense. 

Option3Ventures is a cybersecurity investment specialist with a strategy that focuses on private equity – and on companies aiming to further our national security. We have the experience necessary to identify solid investments and deliver significant returns for our investors. Contact Option3Ventures to learn more about our cybersecurity investment strategies today.


You Might Also Like...